Deep-rust brick home entry with a glazed dark door, limestone steps and burgundy oakleaf hydrangea.

The Old Baker's Square Site Serves Breakfast Again, Starting at 7 a.m.

November 5, 2026

All through September, people kept walking into an unfinished building on Skokie Boulevard to ask when it would open. Danny Shamoon, the Glenview owner of the new Buttermilk Café at 200 Skokie Blvd., told The Record North Shore that "several hungry people" came through the doors every day while crews were still striping the parking lot and waiting on equipment deliveries.

Buttermilk opened in mid-October. That fills the former Baker's Square, which closed in 2019 and left the lot empty for six years. Buttermilk opens at 7 a.m. every day, earlier than any of the other spots that started serving Wilmette mornings over the past year.

Two plans came and went before this one

Several plans for 200 Skokie Blvd. ended before any of them served a meal. The Record lists two public attempts to rebuild the site after Baker's Square closed. Murray Bros. Caddyshack pulled out in 2021–22. The Village Board turned down a McDonald's proposal in 2023–24. Shamoon bought the property in 2025 and has been rehabbing the existing building since.

The Village helped with this one. In 2025, Wilmette trustees unanimously approved an economic incentive agreement with Shamoon and Buttermilk. It covers up to $150,000 in sales-tax remittance over no more than 10 years. Under the agreement, the Village keeps the first $20,000 in sales-tax dollars, Buttermilk gets the next $30,000, and after that the revenue is split. For scale, $150,000 spread over a decade averages $15,000 a year at most, which is small next to six years of a dark building on one of the village's busiest commercial roads.

Shamoon said the delays came from wanting the room finished before opening it. He also said rain held up the buildout:

"Everyone has a sentimental attachment to this location and I don't want to bring something that is not 100% to everybody."

He told The Record that in September, shortly before opening.

What a 180-seat breakfast room adds

Buttermilk began in Geneva in 2014 and later opened in Downers Grove, Naperville and Vernon Hills. Wilmette is its fifth location and its first franchise. The Wilmette room is the biggest of the new breakfast spots. Earlier reporting cited by The Record puts it at about 180 seats:

  • More than 100 seats in the main dining room
  • 38 seats in a sun room
  • 16 seats on a patio

The menu sticks to breakfast and lunch. Breakfast covers omelets, skillets, pancakes and French toast plates, plus the biscuits the chain is known for. Lunch adds sandwiches, burgers and salads. The restaurant runs 7 a.m. to 2:30 p.m., Monday through Sunday, the same hours as every other Buttermilk location. Buttermilk's website has an online waitlist for Wilmette, and its SpotOn page lets you check in at the host stand or join the list remotely. If you're bringing a big group on a weekend morning, join the list from home before you leave.

The other new mornings start later and run longer

Buttermilk is the earliest of the four, but the other three cover hours it doesn't. They're spread across different parts of town too: one by the Metra tracks, one at the lakefront plaza and one on Central Avenue downtown. Here are all four, by the hours each one posts:

Spot Where Opens Morning food ends Closed
Buttermilk Café 200 Skokie Blvd. 7 a.m. daily 2:30 p.m. close No days listed
Sweet Moon Café 1222 Washington Ct. 8 a.m. 6 p.m. close Tuesdays
The Henry Plaza del Lago 8 a.m. daily 11 a.m. weekdays, 4 p.m. weekends No days listed
Lucky Jackson's 1141-A Central Ave. 9 a.m. at its soft opening Coffee and pastries in the mornings Not listed

Weekend hours vary the most. The Henry's weekday breakfast ends at 11 a.m., but its weekend brunch runs from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. On a Saturday or Sunday, that's the latest sit-down brunch among the new spots, an hour and a half after Buttermilk closes. The Henry also has a coffee bar open daily and serves lunch and dinner until 10 p.m. Patch reported in May that the restaurant's mornings would include pastries and specialty coffee. Modern Luxury confirmed it was open by June 8.

Lucky Jackson's, an all-day lounge on Central Avenue, has been in soft opening since New Year's Eve, according to The Record's January report. Chris and Margie Karabas run it in partnership with Valley Lodge Tavern, in a former private room most recently used by FoodHaul. When The Record covered the opening, the morning plan was coffee and pastries starting at 9 a.m.

Sweet Moon makes the Metra stop a place to eat

Buttermilk took over the town's longest-vacant restaurant site. Sweet Moon Café filled a storefront at 1222 Washington Court, next to the Metra station. It replaced Fuel Fusion, which closed in September 2025.

Co-founders Aigerim Mambetova and Marlen Alchinov started Sweet Moon in 2021, and their first shop is in Chicago's Lincoln Square/Ravenswood area. The Wilmette café is their second. Their niece, Zhannat Raiymbek, manages it. Patch describes a menu that mixes Central Asian, Eastern European and American cooking. It has sweet and savory pastries, breakfast and lunch, coffee and smoothies, with vegan and vegetarian options. The Record named honey cakes, solyanka soup, syrniki and omelets among its specialties and bestsellers.

Sweet Moon runs 8 a.m. to 6 p.m., Wednesday through Monday. That's late enough to pick up a honey cake on the way home from the train. It's closed on Tuesdays, so on a Tuesday the closest new morning option is The Henry's coffee bar at Plaza del Lago or Buttermilk on Skokie Boulevard.

Breakfast first, then the rink

The Wilmette Park District has these dates on the calendar at Centennial Ice Rinks, 2300 Old Glenview Road, and nearby:

  • Friday, Nov. 6: T.G.I.F. public skate, 7:30 to 9 p.m. Admission is $10, and skate rental is $5.
  • Nov. 25 through Dec. 11: Santa's Mailbox at the Mallinckrodt Park Gazebo.
  • Sunday, Dec. 13: The free Holiday Exhibition at Centennial Ice Rinks, 1:30 to 3:30 p.m.
  • Thursday, Dec. 24: Skate with Santa at Centennial.
  • Thursday, Dec. 31: New Year's Eve skate at Centennial.

The Holiday Exhibition on Dec. 13 lines up with breakfast. Buttermilk serves until 2:30 p.m. on Sundays and The Henry's brunch runs until 4, so either one fits around a 1:30 start. The Park District's free outdoor rinks open later in the season. It hasn't set a date because they open when winter weather allows.

At the Geoff Brown Team, we've been watching 200 Skokie Blvd. for years, and we're glad to see breakfast served there again. If you're wondering what new openings like Buttermilk and Sweet Moon mean for the value of a home near Skokie Boulevard or the Metra station, ask us for a free home valuation and we'll walk you through the numbers on your block.

Work With Us

With personalized strategies and unmatched local insight, the Geoff Brown Team ensures every client’s transaction is smooth, successful, and stress-free.